First Merchants Bank

πŸ’³ Finance & Insurance Β· Dublin

Nope to NeverBetween really bad and never again.
10

total experiences

40%

replied on google

Most reported issues

AI-classified. Tap a category to filter the experiences below.

Experiences

NeverWait & DelaysFrom Google Reviews
9 days ago

Excessive wait times and poor customer service at the bank branch.

NeverBilling & ChargesFrom Google Reviews
Aug 6, 2026

The bank charges excessive daily overdraft fees.

NoCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Sep 11, 2025

Debit card was never ordered by the bank employee

Business reply on Google

Jessie, we are sorry to hear about the issue you described with your new HSA card. We understand how frustrating it is to wait for a debit card. Thank you for your kind words about our Sawmill Banking Center staff. If you would like to discuss the details about your delayed card order, so we can look into what occurred, please contact your local banking center or call Customer Care at 1-800-205-3464. Our hours in Customer Care are Monday-Friday 8:00 AM-8:00 PM and Saturday 9:00 AM – 3:00 PM.

NeverBilling & ChargesFrom Google Reviews
Jul 20, 2024

bank failed to honor promotion and charged account closing fee

Business reply on Google

David, thank you for letting us know. We're sorry to hear you had an experience that clearly did not meet your expectations. This is something we take very seriously. We want to help you by escalating this to a VP Market Leader to ensure you get priority service. Please provide us with good contact information (phone number and/or email) and a good time to reach you. You can provide this by calling 1.800.205.3464, emailing [email protected], or filling out the contact form on our website at https://www.firstmerchants.com/contact. Please know that we are committed to quickly making this right. Our Market Leader will attentively work with you to solve your issue.

NeverBilling & ChargesFrom Google Reviews
Jan 20, 2023

Bank error caused negative account balance and frequent ATM outages.

Business reply on Google

Brad, we are very sorry to hear you had a less than positive experience at our Sawmill Banking Center location and would like to have our Vice President, Retail Market Leader contact you personally about your experience. Please contact our Customer Service Team by calling 1.800.205.3464 or emailing [email protected] with good contact information (phone/email) and we will be in touch.

NeverBilling & ChargesFrom Google Reviews
Feb 19, 2022

The bank charges excessive fees to customers.

NeverBilling & ChargesFrom Google Reviews
Jun 8, 2021

The bank increased fees and reduced operating hours after a merger.

NeverCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Nov 9, 2019

ATM deposit failure and poor customer service regarding overdraft practices

Business reply on Google

Jessica - We recently came across your review. We're sorry to hear that you had a frustrating experience and want you to know that we do deeply value you and appreciate you as our customer.

NeverCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Jul 21, 2018

Bank refused to cash check despite customer providing multiple identification documents.

NopeRefund & ReturnFrom Google Reviews
Jan 23, 2013

Manager refused to process a fee refund despite supervisor approval.